Quality or Quantity Online Reviews, Which is Better for Local Reputation Marketing?

Quantity Versus Quality for reviews

Quantity Versus Quality for reviews

Online reviews play a large part in the development of your small business’ online reputation.  For that reason, many small businesses work hard to convince their customers to post reviews on all the popular review sites, hoping it will maximize their online reputations.  But is it really necessary to build up as many online reviews as you possibly can for your small business . . . or is it possible that, when it comes to good reviews, a little bit goes a long way?  What is better, quality or quantity?  The answer is not a simple one, and can’t be put in black and white terms.

  1.   In terms of exposure and search engine optimization, it only makes sense that you should want as many reviews for your small business as possible.  That is because search engines notice when people talk about your small business, and it makes your business seem more relevant to the online community.  Also, customers who are researching your business on review sites will undoubtedly consider the number of reviews as an indication of your credibility (even though it may have nothing to do with your level of service).  For these reasons, it is a good thing to have many business reviews.  However, it is also important to understand that numerous poor-quality reviews may do nothing for your small business at all . . . and may even detract from your local reputation marketing campaign by way of association.  That’s where quality comes in.
  2.   What makes a quality review?  Quality reviews give plenty of detail about the customer’s experience with your business.  For example, instead of simply saying, “the food was good” (which gives readers very little to go on), a quality review might say something more along the lines of “the filet mignon was cooked to perfection, and served with a side of the restaurant’s delectable house-recipe garlic mashed potatoes.”  A high quality review paints a picture, and tempts potential customers to try out your business.  After reading the previous example, it should be very clear how one high-quality review can easily trump a handful of bland and generic reviews and improve your local reputation marketing campaign.


The quality/quantity balance.  What’s ideal?  Well, high-quality reviews, and a lot of them!  But until you get to that point, try to focus on bringing in quality, well-written reviews – one at a time – and go from there.

Local Reputation Marketing is a complex process, but it is also tantamount to your small business success.  To make the most of your online reputation, you may want to enlist the help of qualified and competent professionals like us, Two Blind Marketers & Associates.  We can be reached by phone, at 602-487-8733, or by email: michael@twoblindmarketers.com.


About Adam

Adam started out his career in the restaurant industry working for several local restaurants and restaurant franchises. He eventually became a self-taught Chef and a business owner of his own catering company in 1994. It was at this time he started learning about marketing. Several years later, the internet marketing industry exploded and he started learning about online marketing with the help of Michael. Then in 2009, he joined the Two Blind Marketers team as a content editor and WordPress specialist. In 2012, he decided to try his hand at doing work on his own and left the company; it was during this period that he became a Social Media expert. Suddenly in 2014, the CEO of Two Blind asked Adam back as the Executive Creative Director. Adam is now back with the team and helping clients with reputation marketing campaigns, mobile marketing campaigns, and social media marketing campaigns.

1 Comment